Home Community General Football Your top 5 PL greats

Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 49 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #211819
    CM
    Participant

      I remember having these discussions on the old sites and now we had another decade of PL football, the list of all time greats has changed-

      My top 5 greatest PL players –

      1. De Bruyne, the greatest midfielder I have seen in the PL and the in my opinion the greatest player I have seen the PL era. He is literally Scholes, Gerrard and Beckham moulded in one. The way he sets the tempo like Scholes use to. Crosses the ball like Beckham did and his box to box abilities like Gerrard. A game changer when his team needs him.

      2. Henry, one of the most consistent players in the PL era. Had fans on the edge of their seats. Magician and was instrumental in Arsenal’s success.

      3. Ronaldo, only PL player to win the world footballer of the year and Balon d’Or. Was exceptional between 2006-2009. The best player in the world in 2008 and won the PL and CL for United.

      4. Salah, has become Liverpool’s greatest ever attacking player in my opinion. His stats speak for themselves. Came in 2017 with very little hype and took the league by the scruff of the neck.

      5. Van Dijk, the greatest CB in PL history. How many games did players struggle to run past him. Changed Liverpool fortunes. His 1st 2-3 years at Liverpool were something else. No CB has come close to.

      _____________________________

      React below πŸ‘‡

      *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

      Loading spinner
      #211857
      sean the sailor
      Participant

        Difficult one cm

        Ill have to think about it mate

        _____________________________

        React below πŸ‘‡

        *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

        Loading spinner
        #211861
        Editor
        Keymaster

          Someone hacked your account CM? Van Dijk the top CB? πŸ˜…. Not a chance for me. He had a good 2 seasons but I don’t think he has anywhere near the longevity as CBs like Terry, Rio, Kompany, Vidic etc. I thought he made a lot of mistakes last season.

          Off the top of my head and in no particular order, mine are:

          KDB
          Salah
          Rooney
          Henry
          Kane/Shearer (tough to choose here)

          I think all the above have longevity and played their best football in this league

          _____________________________

          React below πŸ‘‡

          *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

          Loading spinner
          #211862
          Mikus LFC
          Participant

            Aguero often gets overlooked in these debates. He was one of the best strikers in this league, and imo probably gave City the edge over us in our battles with them. Such a clever striker that could finish from any angle and scored some very important goals. Did it year in year out.

            _____________________________

            React below πŸ‘‡

            *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

            Loading spinner
            #211864
            sean the sailor
            Participant

              Vvd has had 4 good seasons ed but i agree. Terry or rio best for me.

              Id have gerrard over kdb. Scholes and lampard aswell.

              _____________________________

              React below πŸ‘‡

              *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

              Loading spinner
              #211865
              Chucky McChuckface
              Participant

                Got to have Scholes in there, and Veira too…

                Not sure about Salah, cracking player as he is, he hasn’t been at it as long as quite a few others… same reasoning as with DVD too, cracking player but not for as long as others…

                _____________________________

                React below πŸ‘‡

                *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                Loading spinner
                #211867
                Rover
                Participant

                  Wow Beckenbauer the greatest German player is also gone. He was a genius with the ball.

                  _____________________________

                  React below πŸ‘‡

                  *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                  Loading spinner
                  #211869
                  sean the sailor
                  Participant

                    So many players to pick

                    Roy keane before kdb aswell

                    _____________________________

                    React below πŸ‘‡

                    *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                    Loading spinner
                    #211870
                    Editor
                    Keymaster

                      Yeah what I meant with Van Dijk Sean was that IMO he’s had 2 outstanding seasons. The rest have been good but not at the absolute elite standard he’d set previously. It’s staying at that standard for a long time which imo sets apart the greatest of their generation.

                      _____________________________

                      React below πŸ‘‡

                      *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                      Loading spinner
                      #211871
                      Editor
                      Keymaster

                        Keane another good shout Sean. Had absolutely everything. I find he often today gets wrongly labeled as a defensive midfield destroyer type but he really had it all did Keane.

                        _____________________________

                        React below πŸ‘‡

                        *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                        Loading spinner
                        #211873
                        Nike19
                        Participant

                          When I have a bit more time, haha. I’d have to break this down into different eras to try and avoid dismissing players from Previous decades. I’m looking at Inspiration, Winners and Decorated with Success.

                          Eric Cantona and Ryan Giggs I could name from the 90s. Will come back to this later.

                          _____________________________

                          React below πŸ‘‡

                          *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                          Loading spinner
                          #211874
                          Makaveli
                          Blocked

                            Top 5 is too difficult for me.

                            As for Van Dijk, I would have him in there as before he was given that horror tackle, he was the best defender that I’ve ever seen.
                            He wasn’t top level last season because he took a long time to recover. Look at him now though.

                            In those 2 seasons, Van Dijk went over a year without a single player dribbling past him, in all comps and I think we made the final of the CL during that time.
                            Before people say that isn’t THAT amazing, remember that Liverpool played with a very high line then.

                            That all said, I totally understand why people don’t want to include him but at his best, he was better than any of the other names mentioned. He’s also gotten back to it now.

                            I also don’t see a way not to have Gerrard in there. I think people are forgetting how crazy good he was but it’s a 5 man list and there are so many PL greats. It’s quite frustrating actually.

                            _____________________________

                            React below πŸ‘‡

                            *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                            Loading spinner
                            #211876
                            Makaveli
                            Blocked

                              “It’s staying at that standard for a long time which imo sets apart the greatest of their generation. ”

                              Yes but let’s remember that the reason he wasn’t at that standard had nothing to do with his talent or performance levels. He was attacked by the Everton Jester and took an injury that ends careers.

                              It isn’t like he just started playing poorly. People were saying he was past it. I have gotten a few things wrong (like Nunez) but I called the Van Dijk situation. Ya, I actually got something right! lol

                              Keane is hard to omit also ya… I would have him ahead of Scholes but I know most won’t agree.

                              _____________________________

                              React below πŸ‘‡

                              *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                              Loading spinner
                              #211877
                              Editor
                              Keymaster

                                I personally don’t think VVD was anywhere near the level of Rio, Terry or Kompany Mak in all honesty. I think he’s fortunate to have played in an era where he’s not up against the likes of Henry, Shearer, Ruud, Van Persie, Bergkamp, Rooney, Torres etc every week like those were. Haaland aside, the strikers these days just aren’t as good imo. That’s why these kind of lists are always a nightmare because we all have biases,me included.

                                _____________________________

                                React below πŸ‘‡

                                *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                Loading spinner
                                #211878
                                Adlab
                                Participant

                                  Nearly impossible
                                  Ronaldo
                                  KDB
                                  Salah
                                  Aguero
                                  Henry
                                  Bergkamp
                                  Scholes

                                  etc etc It’s impossible

                                  _____________________________

                                  React below πŸ‘‡

                                  *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                  Loading spinner
                                  #211879
                                  Editor
                                  Keymaster

                                    This was before his injury Mak. The best CB ever in the league?!

                                    https://talksport.com/football/758750/virgil-van-dijk-stats-news-mistakes-leading-to-goals-liverpool/

                                    _____________________________

                                    React below πŸ‘‡

                                    *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                    Loading spinner
                                    #211880
                                    Adlab
                                    Participant

                                      Then there’s
                                      Shearer
                                      Yaya
                                      Too many!

                                      _____________________________

                                      React below πŸ‘‡

                                      *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                      Loading spinner
                                      #211881
                                      Makaveli
                                      Blocked

                                        Fair enough Ed, you’re talking about some seriously top-tier defenders.
                                        As for that article, how many games was that into the PL start? I#’d say not many. I don’t remember the scenarios that led to these goals, so I can’t comment on them but having watched him in pretty much every match that he’s played for us (take out a handful), I have come to expect a top level performance from him, and I am almost never let down./

                                        He’s human, and he does have some poor performances in there. So have all the other greats, but with Van Dijk (last season aside), they are so few and far between.
                                        (if this is slightly wrong, do correct me) Since he’s come here, he’s played I think 90 PL matches at Anfield and lost only 1.
                                        That’s incredible, again, especially for a team that doesn’t just sit back.

                                        I am not coming out and saying you’re wrong. We have our own lists (or partial in my case) and I haven’t seen a name yet who isn’t/wasn’t a footballing god.

                                        It really doesn’t feel right to not have Bergkamp in there but I can’t fit him into a 5 man list.

                                        _____________________________

                                        React below πŸ‘‡

                                        *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                        Loading spinner
                                        #211884
                                        Editor
                                        Keymaster

                                          That’s it Mak. We all have different lists. I’d hazard a guess that you’ll probably never hear the same 5 names if you asked everyone you know that question. Even polls are tricky as they’re often weighted in favour of those teams with the most fans.

                                          _____________________________

                                          React below πŸ‘‡

                                          *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                          Loading spinner
                                          #211900
                                          CM
                                          Participant

                                            🀣

                                            Noone has hacked my account.

                                            1 of the reasons why I have Van Dijk as 1 of the best CBs ever and in my top 5 greatest PL players is what he brought to Liverpool.

                                            Liverpool were averaging 75 points and he arrived and they were instantly competing against City, who set the benchmark of 95 points+ to win the league. No CB or player has added that to a club. City were blessed with many quality players. So were Liverpool with Mane and Salah, but Van Dijk took them to a different level where he gave them an extra 20+ points. Without him, City would have ran away with league titles every season, that’s how good Van Dijk is and was during those seasons.

                                            Agree about longevity, Van Dijk peaked fairly late in his career, but no CB can close to him during his peak years.

                                            _____________________________

                                            React below πŸ‘‡

                                            *hover/click on the number below the reaction to see who reacted

                                            Loading spinner
                                          Viewing 20 posts - 1 through 20 (of 49 total)
                                          • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.